Too Much Time Grading Papers? Why did I assign this paper?
If every student submitted an essay, the College Board needed to grade 1. Since the essay was first offered with the writing section inthe College Board has relied on human graders to evaluate the student work. Inthe ETS Educational Testing Service offered one of the first automatic essay scorers, called e-rater, and testing companies have had more than 15 years to improve upon that earlier model.
The analytical writing assignment is scored by a human as well as a computer, and the two scores are averaged together. By incorporating a computer into the grading process, the GMAT not only saves half the cost of grading the essay, but also is able to perform an objective analysis of sentence structure, word count, and complexity that a human reader would not have the time to complete.
With a human reader assessing the coherence of the argument and the computer comparing the essay with its database of essays, the GMAT can enjoy the best of both worlds. The fact that both tests have expressed a desire to move to a digital format in the coming decade makes the transition that much simpler: Only one human reader would be required to follow up and ensure that the computer graded the essay appropriately.
Naturally, we had to test out the automated essay grader for ourselves. The computer grader, like its human predecessors, knows the limits of a short essay.
Thus far, we noticed that the essay grader does a good job of identifying irrelevant, repeated material.
It also evaluates the length when determining its score. To test the program further, we asked ourselves how the grader would respond to a nonsensical essay that used all the right words and sentence structure, even referencing rhetorical devices and making quotations of the passage.
Try and make sense of the following introduction, written by one of our more linguistically creative tutors. The essay asked students to evaluate the rhetorical devices used by Bogard, who in a persuasive essay laments the diverse and damaging effects of light pollution on humans and animals.
Darkness can symbolize a protean notion of absolute nihilism, floating endlessly in a void without any smattering of perception or purpose.
Bogard embraces this absence and sees darkness as a lofty pursuit necessary for absolute harmony within our fractured post-modern existence. For when we lose the dark, we become absorbed by the light and the nocturnal chimeras of our subconscious cannot take flight.
Using alliterative juxtapositions, carcinogenic conceits, and allusions to fiscal collapse, Borgard persuades the audience that we need to embrace the abyss in order to keep balance in an increasingly fractured and oppressive world.
Nicely done, automated grader. In addition to the essay grader which provides scores for Tests 1 and 2, Khan Academy also provides more personalized feedback.
To serve the students looking for more in-depth analysis, the College Board partnered with TurnItIn to give specific line-by-line suggestions for the practice essay section. Students can write essays and receive comments on particular sections of their essays based on their reading, analysis, and writing abilities.
The College Board and ACT have their work cut out for them to persuade colleges and universities that their essays are predictive of college success for applicants. Despite the initially lukewarm reception to the redesigned essays, the College Board is investing resources into electronic essay grading, demonstrating its belief that the exercise provides a valuable metric for colleges.
We can expect at least one set of human eyes to continue grading student essays in the short term, but if the Khan Academy essay grader is any indication, even that role may be close to retirement.
Applerouth is a trusted test prep and tutoring resource. We combine the science of learning with a thoughtful, student-focused approach to help our clients succeed. Call or email us today at PREP or info applerouth.Save Teacher Weekends: 7 Ways to Spend Less Time Grading Essays.
You don’t have to give your entire life over to grading. write a conclusion. Grading these small chunks only takes a few seconds of your time, and by the time students compile their final essay, the piece will be much more polished and ready to shine.
Grading Overload: 12 Time-Saving Assessment Strategies. By: Build in student conference time periodically to help students on big projects or to give feedback on frequently used assignments, like lab reports or essays.
Get the class working on something – SSR time, finishing a worksheet, or researching information for a project . Unfortunately, all too often we find that students don’t use our feedback.
We wonder if all that time spent giving it was really worth the effort. What can we do to shorten grading time and give feedback that students will read and .
Incorporating and Grading Writing As with test construction, the quality of a writing assignment or essay exam can often determine the quantity of time spent grading; . matters (e.g., preparation, grading papers, parent conferences).
For private school teachers, the outside-school hours spent both in school-related activities with students (e.g., coaching or tutoring. The time it takes to grade student papers is the chief reason for our dislike of the chore. How can you make marking student writing more time effective?
Walvoord and Anderson in Effective Grading: A Tool for Learning and Assessment in College () directly address this concern.